Pre-order your

Thanksgiving

Desserts

Order now!

  1. Place your order today.

  2. Pick it up Wednesday, November 26, 2025.

  3. Enjoy!

Can’t decide what your family’s favorite will be? Try before you buy! We will have individual servings of all of our Thanksgiving pies & desserts available for purchase in the shop in the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving.

Thanksgiving Dessert Menu

  • Maple Pumpkin Pie - $32

    A creamy pumpkin pie infused with warm maple sweetness and topped with whipped vanilla cream.

    A signature item of Short N Sweet Bakery Cafe's Thanksgiving is the maple pumpkin pie with whipped cream decorations around the edge and a maple leaf-shaped cookie in the center.

  • Cranberry Shortbread Cake - $30

    Buttery shortbread layered with tart cranberry filling and golden crumble topping.

    Close-up of Short N Sweet Bakery Cafe in Hilo's cranberry shortbread cake topped with dollops of buttery shortbread cake dough, placed on a wooden cutting board, with pumpkins and hay in the background.

  • Salted Caramel Macnut Pie - $39

    A rich, nutty pie filled with macadamia nuts and drizzled with luscious salted caramel.

    An overhead view of a caramel nut cheesecake garnished with whipped cream and caramel drizzle around the edges, placed on a white patterned tablecloth.

  • Pumpkin Crunch - $38

    Layers of spiced pumpkin custard, shortbread crush, topped with a smooth whipped cream finish.

    Slices of pumpkin cake with white frosting on a wooden platter, with pumpkins and hay bales in the background.

  • Pumpkin Shape Dubai Bar - $14.95

    Pumpkin-shaped chocolates filled with creamy pistachio-tahini and crisp kataifi layers.

    Four pumpkin-shaped Dubai chocolates with metallic bronze and gold finishes, arranged on a white circular surface with a blurred bokeh background.
Pre-Order your Thanksgiving Desserts Today